view tests/test-convert-svn-startrev.t @ 33207:895ecec31c70

revlog: add an experimental option to mitigated delta issues (issue5480)

The general delta heuristic to select a delta do not scale with the number of
branch. The delta base is frequently too far away to be able to reuse a chain
according to the "distance" criteria. This leads to insertion of larger delta (or
even full text) that themselves push the bases for the next delta further away
leading to more large deltas and full texts. This full text and frequent
recomputation throw Mercurial performance in disarray.

For example of a slightly large repository

  280 000 files (2 150 000 versions)
  430 000 changesets (10 000 topological heads)

Number below compares repository with and without the distance criteria:

manifest size:
    with:    21.4 GB
    without:  0.3 GB

store size:
    with:    28.7 GB
    without   7.4 GB

bundle last 15 00 revisions:
    with:    800 seconds
             971 MB
    without:  50 seconds
              73 MB

unbundle time (of the last 15K revisions):
    with:    1150 seconds (~19 minutes)
    without:   35 seconds

Similar issues has been observed in other repositories.


Adding a new option or "feature" on stable is uncommon. However, given that this
issues is making Mercurial practically unusable, I'm exceptionally targeting
this patch for stable.

What is actually needed is a full rework of the delta building and reading
logic. However, that will be a longer process and churn not suitable for stable.

In the meantime, we introduces a quick and dirty mitigation of this in the
'experimental' config space. The new option introduces a way to set the maximum
amount of memory usable to store a diff in memory. This extend the ability for
Mercurial to create chains without removing all safe guard regarding memory
access. The option should be phased out when core has a more proper solution
available.

Setting the limit to '0' remove all limits, setting it to '-1' use the default
limit (textsize x 4).

#require svn svn-bindings

  $ cat >> $HGRCPATH <<EOF
  > [extensions]
  > convert =
  > EOF
  $ convert()
  > {
  >     startrev=$1
  >     repopath=A-r$startrev-hg
  >     hg convert --config convert.svn.startrev=$startrev \
  >         --config convert.svn.trunk=branches/branch1 \
  >         --config convert.svn.branches="  " \
  >         --config convert.svn.tags= \
  >         --datesort svn-repo $repopath
  >     hg -R $repopath log -G \
  >         --template '{rev} {desc|firstline} files: {files}\n'
  >     echo
  > }

  $ svnadmin create svn-repo
  $ svnadmin load -q svn-repo < "$TESTDIR/svn/startrev.svndump"

Convert before branching point

  $ convert 3
  initializing destination A-r3-hg repository
  scanning source...
  sorting...
  converting...
  3 removeb
  2 changeaa
  1 branch, changeaaa
  0 addc,changeaaaa
  o  3 addc,changeaaaa files: a c
  |
  o  2 branch, changeaaa files: a
  |
  o  1 changeaa files: a
  |
  o  0 removeb files: a
  
  

Convert before branching point

  $ convert 4
  initializing destination A-r4-hg repository
  scanning source...
  sorting...
  converting...
  2 changeaa
  1 branch, changeaaa
  0 addc,changeaaaa
  o  2 addc,changeaaaa files: a c
  |
  o  1 branch, changeaaa files: a
  |
  o  0 changeaa files: a
  
  

Convert at branching point

  $ convert 5
  initializing destination A-r5-hg repository
  scanning source...
  sorting...
  converting...
  1 branch, changeaaa
  0 addc,changeaaaa
  o  1 addc,changeaaaa files: a c
  |
  o  0 branch, changeaaa files: a
  
  

Convert last revision only

  $ convert 6
  initializing destination A-r6-hg repository
  scanning source...
  sorting...
  converting...
  0 addc,changeaaaa
  o  0 addc,changeaaaa files: a c