comparison tests/test-check-interfaces.py @ 33807:b70029f355a3

tests: verify that peer instances only expose interface members

Our abstract interfaces are more useful if we guarantee that
implementations conform to certain rules. Namely, we want to ensure
that objects implementing interfaces don't expose new public
attributes that aren't part of the interface. That way, as long as
consumers don't access "internal" attributes (those beginning with
"_") then (in theory) objects implementing interfaces can be swapped
out and everything will "just work."

We add a test that enforces our "no public attributes not part
of the abstract interface" rule.

We /could/ implement "interface compliance detection" at run-time.
However, that is littered with problems.

The obvious solutions are custom __new__ and __init__ methods.
These rely on derived types actually calling the parent's
implementation, which is no sure bet. Furthermore, __new__ and
__init__ will likely be called before instance-specific attributes
are assigned. In other words, they won't detect public attributes
set on self.__dict__. This means public attribute detection won't
be robust.

We could work around lack of robust self.__dict__ public attribute
detection by having our interfaces implement a custom __getattribute__,
__getattr__, and/or __setattr__. However, this incurs an undesirable
run-time penalty. And, subclasses could override our custom
method, bypassing the check.

The most robust solution is a non-runtime test. So that's what this
commit implements. We have a generic function for validating that an
object only has public attributes defined by abstract classes. Then,
we instantiate some peers and verify a newly constructed object
plays by the rules.

Differential Revision: https://phab.mercurial-scm.org/D339

33807:b70029f355a3

# Test that certain objects conform to well-defined interfaces.

from __future__ import absolute_import, print_function

from mercurial import (
    httppeer,
    localrepo,
    sshpeer,
    ui as uimod,
)

def checkobject(o):
    """Verify a constructed object conforms to interface rules.

    An object must have __abstractmethods__ defined.

    All "public" attributes of the object (attributes not prefixed with
    an underscore) must be in __abstractmethods__ or appear on a base class
    with __abstractmethods__.
    """
    name = o.__class__.__name__

    allowed = set()
    for cls in o.__class__.__mro__:
        if not getattr(cls, '__abstractmethods__', set()):
            continue

        allowed |= cls.__abstractmethods__
        allowed |= {a for a in dir(cls) if not a.startswith('_')}

    if not allowed:
        print('%s does not have abstract methods' % name)
        return

    public = {a for a in dir(o) if not a.startswith('_')}

    for attr in sorted(public - allowed):
        print('public attributes not in abstract interface: %s.%s' % (
            name, attr))

# Facilitates testing localpeer.
class dummyrepo(object):
    def __init__(self):
        self.ui = uimod.ui()
    def filtered(self, name):
        pass
    def _restrictcapabilities(self, caps):
        pass

# Facilitates testing sshpeer without requiring an SSH server.
class testingsshpeer(sshpeer.sshpeer):
    def _validaterepo(self, *args, **kwargs):
        pass

class badpeer(httppeer.httppeer):
    def __init__(self):
        super(badpeer, self).__init__(uimod.ui(), 'http://localhost')
        self.badattribute = True

    def badmethod(self):
        pass

def main():
    ui = uimod.ui()

    checkobject(badpeer())
    checkobject(httppeer.httppeer(ui, 'http://localhost'))
    checkobject(localrepo.localpeer(dummyrepo()))
    checkobject(testingsshpeer(ui, 'ssh://localhost/foo'))

main()